The Drood Review
The mystery genre's most comprehensive and trusted guide
to new titles.

Drood Review Home


Mystery's Second Century
A forum on the future
of the genre

Second Century home

Original essays
Cathie & John Celestri
Jeanne M. Dams
Terence Faherty
Elizabeth Foxwell
Alan Gordon
Pat Kehde
Jane Langton
Archer Mayor
Barbara Peters
Maureen Tan
Deborah Tuttle

Our thoughts
Jim Combs
Ted Fitzgerald
Jeanne M. Jacobson
Susan Oleksiw
Beth Thoenen
Mary Torkelson

Follow-ups
Barbara D'Amato


Drood Review Home

This site is copyright (c) 2000-3 by The Drood Review.

The Drood Review
484 E. Carmel Dr #378
Carmel, IN 46032

 

 

Susan Oleksiw

First, I think mysteries and detective fiction will enter the mainstream, in the same way that Wilkie Collins’ The Moonstone was a mainstream novel. Second, I think there will be two tiers of crime fiction. The first will be of work as good as Collins’ novels, giving full consideration to the requirements of the genre and treating it with respect; the second tier will continue to be filled with the god-awful stuff that is written by people desperate to be published and read by people who are hoping for a good read and instead get a breathless chase to the end, where they are invariably disappointed. Crime fiction is due to be accepted as one more type of fiction used by good writers to explore ideas and human behavior, just as writers use the coming of age novel, the adventure story, the domestic novel, or the road story to deal with certain themes. There’s no reason for crime fiction to be the "only" type of fiction mystery writers write, and no reason for so-called mainstream writers not to write a mystery now and then. We can’t all be as prolific as Joyce Carol Oates, but we can certainly appreciate her sense of inclusiveness. Part of this requires a maturing of the perspective of readers and publishers, as well as writers, and I certainly think we have arrived.